Lesbian Dating: Life Before the
U-Haul
We Rush Into Relationships
Why is it that lesbians have such a hard time with dating?
You know, going out with one or more women, maybe having sex, and not having to
arrive at any permanent or long-term decisions about the nature of the
relationship.
Why are we in such a hurry to make the relationship
decision? You've seen it happen: two women start seeing each other and
immediately they're a couple. Once they have sex, it's a sure thing: they are
now in a relationship. Perhaps we should think about this. Maybe some of the
problems lesbian relationships face arise from not having dated for longer
periods of time.
Proving Ourselves to the World
Perhaps we
rush into relationships to prove to the homophobic world - and to ourselves -
that lesbians exist. We do have relationships, and they do work. We're always
so thrilled when two women get together - and that makes sense, in the context
of homophobia. But maybe we should be more concerned about the quality of the
relationship, and not assume that being in a relationship is better than being
single.
Skipping the Dating Part
Dating isn't easy. For one thing, some lesbians disapprove
of other lesbians dating more than one woman. You've heard the putdowns -
"She's a player/user/can't commit," and so on, as if dating different
women is inherently wrong. It's easy to see how these stereotypes can develop;
our only role models are straight men. But while there are definitely lesbians
who don't treat women respectfully, we need to avoid thinking in stereotypes.
There are plenty of other reasons why dating can be hard.
Dating
involves risk-taking -meeting new women, initiating conversations,
asking women out, having an evening of conversation with someone we don't know
very well, and maybe nervously thinking about sex (and, if so, how to
initiate). We're not sure what to expect, and we risk being rejected. Many
women also worry about whether they are attractive or desirable. No wonder so
many lesbians skip this part, and rush into relationships.
And that's
not the least of it. As lesbians, there really aren't many places to meet other
lesbians, and the places that do exist aren't always the easiest places in
which to be introduced. And when we're not in lesbian-identified environments,
we aren't always able to spot other lesbians, or find a way to set up a date.
Dating also means coping with undefined situations - not
knowing where you're headed, being unsure of what you mean to each other, and
possibly feeling confused. For some lesbians, that unknown territory feels out
of control and terrifying. To feel more secure, they immediately define the
relationship and set clear parameters around it. But if the definition of their
relationship is coming out of fear rather than what they actually want with a
particular woman, it can be a set-up for failure. And since there are so many obstacles
to dating, some lesbians stay in relationships longer than they want, precisely
because they don't want to date.
Does Long-Term Always Mean Healthy?
As a community, we tend to admire lesbians who are in
long-term relationships. We're starved for good role models. But we applaud
those relationships without even knowing their quality. And we've all seen -
maybe even grown up with - straight married couples who stay together after it
is healthy or good for either of them, because of family and social
expectations, pressure, children, and so on. But we don't have to make the same
mistakes. If we're with the woman we love, and it feels right, that's
wonderful. But if not, we shouldn't let the fear of dating or rejection prevent
us from finding happiness.
Taking Our Time
It takes bravery and often conscious and deliberate effort
not to fall
The Myth of the Perfect Lesbian Relationship
It sometimes feels like a risk to be honest about our
relationships - as if there's an unspoken myth that all lesbian relationships
are perfect and the same. If ours doesn't measure up to the ideal model, there
must be something wrong with us.
Our need to proclaim and protect our love in the context
of a lesbian-hating society often feels like pressure to hide the struggles in
our relationships for fear they'll be used against us. This need to defend our
relationships and present a perfect image can lead to our minimizing and
denying the problems that do exist.
We Create Our Own Relationships
In truth lesbian relationships can vary a great deal. How
we construct our relationships is both a reflection of the wider heterosexual
model as well as a reflection of our own creativity to create relationships
within a void.
With few or no models to look to, we are often freer than
heterosexuals to create relationships of our own choosing rather than ones
based on social conditioning and expectations.
Some lesbian relationships exist outside the mainstream
heterosexual model, operating on entirely different values. They may embrace
non-monogamy, be poly-amorous, live in separate homes for
But it's not always easy to be so inventive. We don't live
in a vacuum, there are social pressures on us. For lesbians, homophobia can
present an obvious pressure and strain on our relationships.
The Pressure of Homophobia
Many lesbian relationships suffer under the critical eyes
of homophobic family and peers. Arguments about whether or not to come out,
with whom and when can occur. Even when there is agreement not to be out, there
may be differences between women about how far to go to hide their
relationship. Where only one woman isn't out, her repeated denial of the
existence of the relationship may leave her partner feeling hurt, insecure, and
unloved. The one who isn't out may even blame and resent her partner who serves
as a reminder of her own secrecy and feelings of guilt. Both women may feel
depressed, irritable, and unhappy and take it out on each other.
Hurt and angry feelings can lead to arguments,
insecurities, and worries about the stability of the relationship. In this
situation, it is vitally important for both women to talk about how they are
feeling, and hear and understand each other's concerns and fears.
Even when
both women are mostly or completely out, homophobia can, take its toll -because
of harassment, fear of harassment, times it's scary to be out and you pull
apart from each other, rumours that get started, assumptions that are made
about you, and so on. Repeatedly framing the problem as homophobia, rather than
an inadequacy on the part of either women, helps to lay the blame where it
belongs and instead of fighting about how to handle situations it is far better
to bond over a mutual problem and find your way through it together.
When there
are differences between women, based on such things as race, culture, age and
sexual identity it can be an additional hurdle to cross. Added to this is the
reality that too often even lesbian friends can be critical and unsupportive of
overt differences between women assuming that it will never work out. This can
be particularly devastating and isolating to a couple - to be rejected by both
the mainstream and their own communities. Although this reluctance on the part
of friends to accept your partner often changes over time, it's still very hard
for couples to be doubly stigmatized. Couple in these situations often feel
like they have to present their relationship and partner as perfect because
everyone is expecting them to fail. This is too much to expect of yourself.
Finding people who support your relationship is so very important, even if it
means going to couple's therapy for awhile.
Having Time Apart
It's not uncommon in the beginning of a relationship for
lesbian couples to spend all of their free time together - basking in each
other's love and mutual discovery. Friends my be dropped, separate activities
cease, and the relationship becomes like a cocoon. This may feel really good to
both women for awhile. But, in time, this total focus on each other decreases
usually with one of the women expressing a need to have space.
She may need time alone, or want to spend time with her
friends. If she's felt it for awhile, it may come out abruptly or desperately.
Either way, her partner may hear her as saying she needs to get away from her.
Feeling hurt or rejected, she may get upset or angry and question her lover's
love or commitment. The one wanting space may feel misunderstood, suffocated
and possibly controlled, and then feel an even greater need for space. Not a
good combination!
Short of lots of mutual understanding
and reassurances at this point or shortly thereafter, many couples end up
arguing. Rather than figuring out how to support each others' needs for
separate time, they may only get time apart after a fight which is not
satisfying for either woman.
Dealing
with differences can be a real challenge for couples. As lesbians, we love that
we're both women - our sameness feels good and right. We delight in each other,
our bodies, doing things together, swapping clothes, sharing food, music, ideas
and laughter. But, when we hit a point, or too many points, of differences we
may feel uncomfortable, scared or angry. From the less important things like
when we go to bed, to more important things like not getting along with each
other's friends or not enjoying the same social activities, eventually we
discover that we have differences.
Our
difficulty dealing with differences may be due to a discomfort with the
separateness they can create, or the fact that differences challenge our
assumptions about the way people or relationships "should be like".
Maybe we think that feeling separate is not okay or means there is a problem
when it's actually a very healthy thing and helps us to feel even closer. Maybe
we're uncomfortable with our own privilege and how that gives us power in the
relationship.
If our
identity is wrapped up in the other person, we may believe that our differences
mean that there is something wrong with us or them but differences are just
that -differences. They don't mean anything more than that - the challenge is
to accept our differences and even rejoice in them. We can learn from each
other's differences. A partner who needs a lot of space may learn how to set
her boundaries clearly and compassionately. A partner who needs less space may
learn the value of space or to not feel abandoned when her lover takes space.
Our inclination can be to suppress differences that arise
- worried that they mean something is wrong with the relationship. But,
suppressing differences only leads to flat, stifled relationships or the
opposite - lots of fighting. Unacknowledged or undervalued differences lead to
resentment, can dampen sexual desires, fuel power imbalances and lead to
despair, frustration and bitter arguments. Letting differences out into the
light of day and not attaching any negative meaning to them goes a long way in
a relationship. Noticing, talking about and appreciating differences can
prevent all sorts of problems.
Dealing With Conflict
When resentments do build up, many women avoid addressing
them.
Many of us are never taught ways of dealing with our anger and
conflict. Many women try very hard to get along and to minimize differences or
feelings of anger and resentment. But, our anger doesn't go anywhere and
usually builds up and comes out in indirect ways which is usually hurtful to
the other person and the relationship.
Airing resentments is really
important and women often have to work at doing this. Taking time to listen to
others' resentments can help. Listening to and understanding each others' anger
goes a long way. It's not about who's right or wrong but about understanding
each others' perspectives.
Sometimes
a good remedy for a relationship problem is to talk to a trusted and supportive
friend about what's going on in your relationship - not in someone else's
relationship! Our struggles are not so very different from each other and we
can learn from hearing how other lesbians have handled their problems -
something we don't get to hear enough about.
Lesbian
Couples and Friends: Is There Enough Love to Go Around?
Why is it that lesbians can neglect or forget their
friends when they get into a relationship? Whether it's the quality and
intensity of our friendships that change, or the fact that we no longer make
new friends, or that we rarely meet with friends independent of our partners,
it always seems to happen once we're involved with someone.
Our Needs Change When We re in a Relationship
Granted, after being in a relationship, our needs and
interests change. Some lesbians want to connect with other couples or develop
mutual friends. Some feel satisfied that their emotional needs are met by their
partners. Others feel that their relationships demand a lot from them
emotionally, leaving them less to offer to friends. While all of these are
reasons to make some shifts, they don't compensate for the loss of a trusted
friend. Or the independence and closeness that can be gained by hanging out
with your own friends.
Friends Can Feel Like a Threat
Some lesbians are convinced that other lesbians are a
threat to their relationship. They're afraid they will lose their partner if
she goes out and has fun with other lesbians. They insist on always getting
together with their partner's friends, and can't understand why she might want
time alone with them. If you feel secure in your relationship, it isn't a big
deal if your lover sees her friends alone, or even if someone flirts with her.
If you don't feel secure in your relationship or don't feel you can trust your
partner, then that's the issue that needs to be addressed, not your lover
seeing her friends.
Feeling Insecure
Some
lesbians feel insecure about any close relationship their partner has, usually
with a single lesbian, but not always. Relatives, men, and straight friends can
all feel like a threat when someone is insecure because of their life
experiences, or when the relationship is going through a hard
time. If you feel insecure because of past experiences, you may
want to see a counsellor to work it out. If it's an issue within your
relationship, you may want to try couple counselling. Whatever the source, it's
important to look at the deeper issue, and not get stuck on the trigger.
If your
conversations remain at the level of your being upset with your partner because
she's spent time with her friends, your partner will only end up resenting you
for interfering with her friendship(s). This, in turn, will create distance and
hostilities between you. Instead, try talking with each other about how you
both feel when she sees friends. If your feelings are connected to past
experiences, talk about that. Ask for what you need from each other to make
this work -- where she sees her friends and you feel more confident about
yourself and the relationship.
Some
lesbians feel fine about their partner seeing friends independently, but may
feel threatened by a particularly close friendship. This can be hard to deal
with. It's important to talk about your feelings with your partner, and
hopefully she will be able to hear and reassure you. Again, the issue is not
about the friendship, but about your wanting to feel close to and secure with
your partner.
We Can t Meet All of Each Others Needs
Some lesbians believe that their partner's friendships are
an indication of something missing in their own relationship, as though they
should be able to meet all of their partner's needs. No one can meet all of
another person's needs. In fact, seeing friends usually improves relationships.
Having enjoyed an evening with a friend, your partner will feel happier and
revitalized which can benefit both of you, especially if you don't give her a
hard time about it.
How We Think About Love
Sometimes underneath these insecurities and jealousies is
the belief that if your partner really loved you, she would love only you. You
might think that if she goes out with a friend at a time when you're free,
she's choosing her friend over you. This is a misunderstanding about love.
Everyone is capable of loving a number of people at the same time. Her choice
to see a friend is just that -- a decision to see her friend. It is not a
competition with you. So don't make it into one by giving her a hard time.
Encourage and support her to see her friends, and do the same for
yourself. If you feel insecure, talk about it. You may find that rather than
threatening your relationship, seeing friends leaves both of you feeling better
about each other.
To Come Out Or
Not To Come Out:
That Is The Question
Coming out
is often presented as something that is not only healthy for us, but our
political duty. But is it realistic to assume that we can always come out
everywhere we go?
There are Different Factors Involved
Our ability to be out depends on how we are feeling, what
we anticipate the outcome to be, and how important it is in that moment. I
mean, let's face it, do we really want to correct every salesperson that
assumes our girlfriend is our sister, daughter, mother, or "only" a
friend? I know I don't. Yet it's been important for me to ask for same-sex
spousal benefits everywhere I have worked.
Not all workplaces and families are the same however, and
some present bigger risks than others. Anyone who says you must be out
everywhere all the time either doesn't understand the possible risks involved,
or hasn't been harassed, disowned, closeted for a long time, lost their job, or
had their life threatened.
Being Out is Important
Being out is important. It's vital for our visibility in
the world and our integrity. When we don't come out, we can feel uncomfortable
or shameful, like we're hiding something bad, or lying about who we are. The
more we come out, the more we resist the sometimes overwhelming opposition to
our existence. We need a visible and vocal presence to respond to the
homophobic backlash. But I don't think that this means that we should feel
guilty for not being out everywhere at all times.
There are Risks Involved
I think it's important that as lesbians we understand--and
not just intellectually--why some lesbian don't come out, or may only come out
in certain areas of their lives. This probably includes all of us some of the
time. There are real threats out there, including being fired, losing family or
We are all Effected by Homophobia
Even if we are able to be out in our jobs, with our
families and friends, and in public, we are still effected by the threat of
homophobia. After all, unless we always behave as freely as we would in a world
free of homophobia, we are censoring ourselves, perhaps without even realizing
it. Even lesbians who make a point of being blatantly out, which I admit to
doing sometimes, are reacting to homophobia and not just being who they are.
In addition to the external risks we face, we are all
affected by the relentless homophobic conditioning from families, religion,
schools, culture, media, etc. These have an accumulated effect on how we feel
about ourselves.
For
example, some lesbians feel insecure about the validity of their sexuality.
This makes a lot of sense in a context where there are very few, if any, models
to affirm our sexuality and to tell us that being lesbian is not only okay, but
is fantastic. Most lesbians go through some period of internalized homophobia.
We need to find ways to talk about this, including how we are effected in the
privacy of our bedrooms. Just because we are out of sight of homophobes doesn't
mean that we can suddenly turn off the effects.
We Need to Choose
It's not
always clear what to do about coming out. Sometimes our fear tells us that
there is danger ahead and we need to be careful and protective. That is a smart
thing to listen to. Other times, it's fear that's getting in our way and there
is no danger. At those times we need to find a way to act or speak through our
fear.
When we come out even when we are afraid, we feel a whole
lot stronger and better about ourselves. But when we come out when it's not the
right time for us we feel pressured or unhappy about it. The trick is figuring
out the difference. Instead of assuming that it is always better to be out,
let's help each other figure out the differences between when it wouldn't
When we first fall in love, we don't expect to break-up.
It may not even occur to us, even if we've been through a break-up already.
We're dizzy with the excitement and euphoria of love, certain that this time
will be different. The longer the relationship continues, the more certain we
become. Yet break-ups do occur.
You May Still be in Love
You may
still be in love, but the distance between you has grown too wide, or the
arguments too frequent and painful that it feels impossible to continue.
Whether you were the one to leave or your lover left you, a break-up usually
means you'll feel sad, disappointed, abandoned, betrayed, scared, confused, and
jealous.
You Won t Always Feel this Way
While it may seem to you that those feelings will never go
away, they can, and will, if you let them run their course, and talk about it.
The temptation may be to run away from your feelings, keep busy, drink, start
dating or use other distractions, but it's crucial that you find ways to let
yourself feel all of your feelings and get the support you need to do that.
It s Can Feel Like a Death
You may go
through some of the same feelings you'd go through if someone you loved died -
in a way breaking up can feel like a death has taken place. You may experience
disbelief, shock, denial, anger, depression, regret, attempts to reconcile,
fear, panic, and then acceptance, hope and the ability to trust again.
Not everyone goes through all of these phases or feelings,
and not necessarily in that order. Many lesbians feel disbelief, fear, sadness,
anger, relief and make attempts to get back together all at the same time. And
many lesbian relationships break-up before they officially break-up. So while
it may seem that someone is doing well after a break-up, maybe she knew for
some time already and hadn't told anyone.
A break-up is rarely easy, even when
it's your choice. There may be a mixture of conflicted feelings - you may want
nothing to do with her and get back together all at the same time. Usually it's
the hardest for the one being left and it can take longer for her to get over
the break-up, after all it wasn't her choice or decision.
Break-Ups Happen in Different Ways
Break-ups
can happens hard and fast, ending in a blow up. Or they can be slow and subtle,
with two women living together for an extended period of time with little or no
communication, sex or happiness. Break-ups can be abrupt, with one woman
suddenly announcing that she is leaving, or they can be gradual, with both
women slowly coming to realize that they don't want to be together anymore. Abrupt
endings may feel more devastating at first, while those that drag on can take
much longer to find clarity and closure.
The truth is, how you feel after a break-up depends on a
lot of things, including how long you were together, how intensely you feel
about your lover, whether or not you chose to break-up, whether or not there
was abuse, what kind of interactions, if any, you still have with your ex, how
and why your past relationships ended, your childhood experiences of loss and
abandonment, and how much support you have.
Losing Your Community at the Same Time
In the lesbian community, you can suddenly feel like your
whole world has shrunk after a break-up. Friends that the two of you knew
together may no longer speak to you, especially if you're the one doing the
leaving.
Regardless
of the situation or our lack of knowledge about the situation, we can be quite
judgmental toward the woman who decides to leave.
Couples
that you spent time with may not know how to relate to you now that you are
single. Social settings in the community that the two of you went to together
may hold painful memories for you, which can be particularly hard in smaller
communities. You might run the risk of bumping into her before you're ready.
Many lesbians find themselves avoiding community events, which leaves them
feeling even more isolated.
How to Relate to Your Ex
Some
lesbians are able to maintain friendships with their ex-partners right away,
others take months or years, and some find it too painful or impossible for
other reasons. Not seeing your ex for some period of time after a break-up can
help in some instances. It can help you to stop trying to save a deadened
relationship, prevent pointless arguments, and give you both time to feel what
it's like to be apart, and to creat a new relationship with each other, it
that's what you decide to do.
Sometimes seeing each other is a distraction from feeling
the pain, sometimes it eases the pain and is an important part of letting go.
There is no right way, only what feels best for both women. When you have
different needs, often the woman needing more space feels pressured or guilty,
while the other feels abandoned and rejected.
We All Need Our Friends
Friends can be invaluable at a time like this. Many are
sympathetic, usually having been through their own break-ups and can help by
providing you with much needed understanding, a sympathetic ear and validation.
Although friends can carry their own baggage about break-ups and be cynical or
dismissive, in effect tell you to "get over her".
This is not supportive and you may find it hard to find
the support you need. Many lesbians go to therapy after a break-up. Therapy can
help you to grieve and let go, as well it can help you to reflect on what
happened. It can be so tempting after a break-up to conclude that relationship
don't work out or that you'll never trust again, and feeling that way can be a
natural part of grief. But at some point you'll want to see what you can learn
about yourself and relationships, lessons that will help rather than hurt you -
lessons that will free you to love again.
Talking About
Lesbian Partner Abuse
Many of us, when we first come out, are drawn to the
lesbian community with the dream of finding an all-embracing, welcoming
community. Abuse in lesbian relationships doesn't even enter the picture. After
all, we are eager to meet other lesbians, find a sexual partner, make friends,
fall in love, and at long last, find a place where being lesbian is not only
accepted, but celebrated. The road getting there may have been a hard one, with
people trying to stop us from being who we are, and ridiculing, rejecting, or
hating us, but finally we have a community.
We Can Ignore or Dismiss Problems
The
rejection, isolation, and violence in our lives as marginalized people can
intensify our desire for a safe and united community. But sometimes this desire
can be so strong, we can make the mistake of dismissing, ignoring, and even
denying problems that exist within the lesbian community.
I have repeatedly made this mistake. When I first heard
about violence in lesbian relationships, I found it hard to believe. It did not
fit my idealized image of the lesbian community. Even when I acknowledged that
it happened, I minimized the reality. "At least it doesn't happen as often
as it does in straight relationships," I would say. I was trying to avoid
how I truly felt about the issue.
I soon realized that it was only by facing the painful
truth about lesbian partner abuse that we could truly make our community the
safe place we want it to be. By dodging or ignoring the issue, we become part
of the problem. We create an environment which isn't receptive to hearing
lesbians speak of their abuse, or to helping them find the safety and support
they deserve.
We Need to Listen to Abused Lesbians
When we don't listen to and support survivors of abuse in
lesbian relationships, we fail to support other lesbians who need us. For it is
lesbians who are in the best position to understand the issues that are
particular to abuse in lesbian relationships -- such as an abused lesbian who
insists to her
parents that her relationship
is wonderful for fear that if they knew, it would confirm their believe that
lesbian relationships aren't stable. Or the lesbian who knows about abuse
dynamics in straight relationships, but is unable to admit or even talk about
the emotional abuse that goes on in hers.
As a community, we are beginning to offer some support to
abused lesbians, but it's usually limited to lesbians that we do not personally
know. Somehow, we have a much harder time believing abuse took place when the
lesbian disclosing it, or her partner, is someone we know. Perhaps it becomes
too real to us. Or maybe it confronts our stereotypes.
Disbelief and the Fear of Talking
Too often I've heard lesbians say that when they disclosed
abuse to another lesbian, they were told: "But I've met her, I can't see
her doing that," or "But you're a strong woman -- why didn't you just
leave?"
For most of us, it can be hard to disclose problems we're
having in our relationships. We might feel embarrassed, ashamed, or protective
of our partner and relationship, and so put on a protective front. Imagine
those feelings of shame and embarrassment being magnified one hundred times,
then another hundred, to the point where you feel the abuse is a negative
reflection on you.
An abused woman will often believe that the abuse proves
there is something wrong with her. Of course, this makes her reluctant to tell
anyone. If the victim is a survivor of child abuse, her shame and trauma are
increased even more, as well as the likelihood for her silence. And of course,
no one likes to be the topic of gossip, and that is one thing that spreads
quickly through the lesbian community.
If the couple has been together for a significant amount
of time, or if either partner is a well-known figure in the lesbian community,
there may be even greater pressure to pretend everything is fine. This may also
be true if the abusive woman is a woman of colour or a member of another
oppressed group; the abused woman may refrain from saying anything in an effort
not to fuel racism or any other "ism."
Partner
abuse may not be overt. If may happen inconsistently, both of which leave the
woman feeling confused and uncertain whether or not abuse has taken place.
Pressure for sex can be misinterpreted by the abused partner as romantic
overtures. Constant criticism may be excused as attempts to help. But whether
the abuse is overt (such as hitting, kicking, pushing, shoving, and forced
participation in any sex acts), or covert (such as emotional manipulation,
isolation, use of control, humiliation, and undermining someone's self-esteem
or free will), it is devastating to a woman's sense of herself and her ability
to make informed choices. It's precisely because abuse makes a person feel
confused, fearful, self-blaming, and ashamed that she is limited in her ability
to trust her feelings, to make decisions, and to protect herself by leaving.
Specific Issues for Abused Lesbians
The impact of partner abuse, whether
experienced by lesbians or straight women, is the same in many ways. However,
because the abuse occurs in the context of homophobia and sexism, there are a
number of things that are different for abused lesbians:
!
Because the abuse involves two women, many people do not
take it seriously, viewing it as "mutual abuse." This is a myth.
!
Many people don't believe that a woman is capable of
causing significant physical damage. Another myth.
!
A lesbian who chooses to call the police may face all
kinds of homophobia, preventing many lesbians from making that call in the
first place.
!
The criminal justice system often does not take abuse in
lesbian relationships seriously, putting lesbians at further risk by not
intervening when called.
!
Parents and friends may be homophobic, making it harder to
talk about the abuse, for fear of proving them right about so-called
"dysfunctional and miserable" lesbian relationships.
! With the
occasional and limited exception, there are no support services specifically for
abused lesbians.
While we know about the kind of violence men can
perpetrate against women, we're usually unprepared for it coming from a woman.
It may be more of a shock, feel like a deeper betrayal, be more isolating, and
be harder to define, given most definitions of abuse exclude lesbians. And
worse, if you and your relationship is closeted, you may find yourself with
even less support than others, and feeling very much alone.
Abused Lesbians Need Safe Places
Having safe and supportive places to talk openly about
partner abuse is critical to healing. Lesbians are rarely provided with
opportunities to feel their pain and anger at having been abused, to reflect on
what happened, and to untangle self-blaming beliefs so that they can move on
from their abusive ex-partners. They often feel they have to avoid social
outings, and may become very isolated in an attempt to avoid the woman who
abused them.
In fact, many lesbians have
no one they can turn to, because everyone they might be able to talk to,
including support services, know, or know of, her partner. Some survivors of
partner abuse recall how they turned to other lesbians for support and received
little or nothing, while their abusers received great amounts. If they mention
this, the women giving support to the abuser might say that they have no way of
knowing who is telling the truth. This is rarely an issue a straight woman will
have to face.
The whole issue of who to support needs to be looked at in
depth on its own. But what I can say here is that both women need support --
the abused woman, to overcome the damage, and the abuser, to stop the abuse and
look at what fueled it. However, the abused woman takes priority, and needs to
be given a place of safety.
Holding Lesbian Abusers Accountable
As a community, we have struggled with little success to
find ways to hold abusers accountable. Some lesbians have spoken of going to a
woman's shelter, only to find their abuser there already, and being turned away
21
themselves. Other lesbians have talked about how, before or after
they disclosed the abuse, they heard that their abusers were claiming that they
had been the abused ones in the relationship.
Listening To Abused Lesbians
Partner
abuse in the lesbian community is an important issue that I hope we can keep on
trying to address. If a lesbian shares her story with you, I hope you can
recognize the great strength it took for her to do that, and I hope you'll
listen supportively, without blame or judgment. There is much strength and love
in our community that we can draw on for inspiration when dealing with this
difficult subject.
Do you
think that it is possible to be lesbian and sexually attracted to men? What
about lesbians who have sexual fantasies that include men? Or lesbians who have
relationships only with women and occasionally have sex with a man? If you have
any of these feelings or experiences, you are not alone, and they don't have to
diminish your lesbian identity.
On the other hand, if the thought of one or all of these
upset or anger you, you are not alone, either. As lesbians, we can be sensitive
about these issues, and with good reason.
Understanding
Why Some Lesbians are Uncomfortable With the Topic
It's not hard to understand why some lesbians might not
trust lesbians or bisexual women who include men in their sex lives. In a world
where we are told that lesbian relationships are a fad, a phase, less
significant than straight relationships, don't last, are unhappy, unstable, and
lacking because there is no male involvement, and that all we need is a
"good fuck," it can be hard to feel open to lesbians or bisexual
women who want, or do have sex with men.
We want the world to recognize lesbian relationships and
to understand that we are perfectly content and sexually fulfilled with women.
It is within this context that it can be hard for some lesbians to hear that
other lesbians' sexual fulfillment includes fantasies and sex with men. It
sounds too familiar to what homophobes say about us, and so we distance
ourselves from them and refuse to listen.
But are we getting anywhere
by not listening to each other? I don't think so. Sometimes, our community can
feel pretty polarized and divided.
Bisexuality May Not Be The Answer
Many people think that there
are two narrowly defined sexual orientations for women --lesbian and straight
-- and that women fall neatly into one or the other category for the rest of their
lives (or at least once they've come out). Deviations from these categories upset a lot of
people, including both those who support and those opposed to lesbian
sexuality. In response, a third category is introduced: bisexuality.
There is a tendency to view bisexuality as fitting anyone
who doesn't neatly fit into the other two; kind of like a "dumping
ground" rather than a viable alternative in its own right. But even this
third category hasn't resolved the issue because it would mean, for example,
grouping women who form all of their emotional and sexual relationships with
women and occasionally have sex with men into the same category as women who
form all of their emotional and sexual relationships with men and occasionally
have sex with women.
Sexuality As a Continuum
Maybe it's
more helpful to view sexuality as being a continuum of different sexual desires
and behaviours, and that it's possible to move a little, or a lot, on the
continuum. Perhaps there is even a continuum of desire and another continuum of
behaviour, which explains why we fantasize about all kinds of things that we
are not interested in acting on. This would explain why lesbians who
occasionally sleep with men identify as lesbian. Most of the time they are at
the far end of the continuum where they have relationships exclusively with
women. A small minority of the time they move on the continuum and enjoy a
night of sex with a man.
Our Sexuality Isn't Simple
Many lesbians (and others,
too) would prefer the simplicity of saying a lesbian is one thing and one thing
only, but it just doesn't reflect the sexual desires and behaviour of all
lesbians, and we don't resolve anything by saying that lesbians who sleep with
men aren't "real" lesbians. The question is whether or not we can
listen to lesbians without judgement, and be open to understanding their
feelings without having to categorize them.
A More Diverse Community
In the end, the fact that
there are lesbians who sometimes have sex with men, and bisexual women, doesn't
diminish or take anything away from the many lesbians who have no sexual desire
for men; nor does it decrease the importance of countering heterosexist and
homophobic myths. We can only gain by acknowledging and respecting the sexual
diversity of our community; in doing that, we gain a richer and more varied
community.
No comments:
Post a Comment